This article is about AfterSell pricing comparison, so if you run a Shopify store, you've likely heard of AfterSell; a powerful post-purchase upsell app that promises to increase your average order value (AOV) by up to 30%.
However, with a monthly pricing ranging from $34.99 to $99 or more, many merchants ask: Is AfterSell worth the investment?
In this article, we break down AfterSell's pricing, features, value, and alternatives so you can make an informed decision.
READ ALSO: How to Use AdCreative.ai for Facebook Ads (Step-by-Step Guide)
What is AfterSell?
AfterSell is a Shopify app designed to help eCommerce merchants boost revenue through post-purchase upsells and cross-sells.
Instead of relying solely on pre-checkout upsells, AfterSell allows you to present high-converting offers right after the customer completes their purchase, without disrupting the checkout experience.
With over 40,000 Shopify brands using the app and more than $500 million in additional revenue generated, AfterSell has earned a solid reputation in the eCommerce world.
AfterSell Pricing Plans (2025)
AfterSell’s pricing is based on the number of monthly store orders. Here's a breakdown:
| Monthly Orders | Pricing |
|---|---|
0 - 50 orders | Free Plan |
51 - 100 orders | $7.99/month |
101 - 200 orders | $14.99/month |
201 - 500 orders | $29.99/month |
501 - 1,000 orders | $49.99/month |
1,000+ orders | Custom/Enterprise |
Note: All paid plans come with a 30-day free trial and access to all core features.
What's Included in Every Plan:
- Unlimited upsell/cross-sell offers
- Custom thank you pages
- Native Shopify checkout support (Shopify Plus only)
- Offer performance analytics
- A/B testing capabilities
- Integrations with Reviews.io, Judge.me, Stamped, and others
Key Features That Justify AfterSell Pricing
1. Post-Purchase Upsell Offers
AfterSell lets you create 1-click upsell and cross-sell offers that customers can accept without re-entering their payment information.
This frictionless experience increases your chances of boosting order value.
2. Advanced Targeting Rules
You can create hyper-personalized offers based on:
- Cart contents
- UTM parameters
- Customer tags
- Purchase history
- Discount codes used
This level of targeting can significantly increase conversions.
3. Custom Thank You Pages
Replace your generic thank-you page with a branded, conversion-focused page that can include:
- Product recommendations
- Embedded videos
- Surveys and reviews
- Countdown timers
4. A/B Testing and Funnel Analytics
Track how each offer performs with real-time analytics, then run A/B tests to optimize your funnels for better conversion and revenue.
5. Shopify Plus Integration
AfterSell is one of the few apps with native support for Shopify Plus stores, enabling true post-purchase offers within the Shopify checkout, a major plus for enterprise-level merchants.
READ ALSO: Top 5 AdCreative.ai Alternatives in 2025 (+ Pros, Cons & Pricing)
Pros and Cons of AfterSell
Pros:
- Proven AOV increase (20-30% on average)
- Easy to set up with drag-and-drop editor
- Strong customer support and onboarding
- Integrates well with top Shopify apps
- 30-day free trial on all plans
Cons:
- Pricing scales with order volume
- Native Shopify checkout integration requires Shopify Plus
- Some features may require slight dev assistance for custom setups
AfterSell Reviews: What Real Users Say
Shopify App Store Rating: 4.9/5 (600+ reviews)
Highlights from Verified Reviews:
"Our AOV jumped by 27% in just 2 weeks of using AfterSell! Setup was a breeze."
"The customer support is next-level. They walked us through customizing every step."
"I’ve tried Rebuy and Zipify, but AfterSell’s upsell funnel was the easiest to optimize."
"The thank-you page editor is amazing, finally a way to monetize it properly."
AfterSell vs. Top Alternatives (2025)
| Feature | AfterSell | Rebuy | Zipify OneClick | Ark Upsell |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Post-Purchase Offers |  |  | | |
Custom Thank You Page | | | | |
Shopify Plus Support | | | | |
A/B Testing | | | | |
Ease of Use | | Moderate | Moderate | Advanced |
When Is AfterSell Worth the Price?
If your store averages 100+ orders per month, AfterSell can easily pay for itself by increasing AOV through post-purchase funnels.
Here’s an example:
- Monthly Orders: 300
- Average Order Value (AOV): $50
- With AfterSell (30% boost): $65
- Monthly Upsell Revenue: 300 x $15 = $4,500
- AfterSell Cost: $29.99
- ROI: Over 140x return on investment
FAQs About AfterSell
Is AfterSell free?
Yes, AfterSell has a free plan for stores with 0–50 monthly orders. All features are accessible during the 30-day trial.
Does AfterSell really increase AOV?
Yes. Most users report a 20–30% increase in AOV within the first month.
Is AfterSell better than Rebuy or Zipify?
If your priority is post-purchase upsells and a customizable thank-you page, AfterSell outperforms most competitors in terms of ease-of-use and ROI.
Can I use AfterSell on Shopify Basic?
Yes. However, native checkout integration is only available on Shopify Plus.
What happens if I exceed my order limit?
You’ll be prompted to upgrade your plan based on your new monthly order volume.
READ ALSO: Sales And Marketing Skills Every Business Should Have
In Summary: Is AfterSell Worth It?
If you’re looking to boost revenue without increasing ad spend, AfterSell offers one of the best ROIs in the Shopify ecosystem.
With flexible pricing, a generous trial, and real-world proof of increased AOV, it’s a must-have for growing eCommerce brands.
Whether you're a new merchant or running a high-volume store, AfterSell helps you turn every transaction into a revenue-maximizing opportunity.
Ready to Try AfterSell?
Click here to start your free trial and start boosting your revenue today.
Ready to Level Up Your Business Skills?
Join my online school, Online Income Academy, for more expert guides, tutorials, and strategies to help you build a successful business. Sign up today!